Skip to main content

RESPONSE TO ENG. JOSEPH GAMA OKELLO: Context and Consideration of Palestinians

By Abunerry, Ayella John Bosco

19th August 2025

On 18th August 2025, Eng. Joseph Gama stated, “I'm for the resettlement of Palestinians in South Sudan. It must be organised with opportunities for them to integrate into the communities. Those of you who have been refugees and got opportunities to resettle in Australia, America, Canada, etc., will agree with me. Our perceptions from the liberation struggle against the Arabs shouldn't cloud our hearts for humanity.”

I wish to respond to Eng. Gama based on three of his strengths: his intellect, his government authority as an official, and his role as a community leader. This response is not an attack but rather rooted in mutual love for patriotism and a correct understanding of what a public figure like him should embody.

1. As an intellectual, Gama can analyse situations in the Middle East and reach tangible conclusions. However, he has diminished his intellectual stature. He did not distinguish between the need to relocate Gazans by Israel, which acts independently under expansionist policies, and a resettlement case handled by UNHCR. Gama did not specify whether the Palestinians' situation is one of refugees or forced resettlement. I remind Gama that no country objects to hosting refugees if it is a call from UNHCR, the official refugee agency. In 2021, Uganda accepted Afghan refugees through an agreement between the Ugandan government (the people) and the UNHCR. That was not a forced resettlement. Is Afghanistan a Christian nation?

2. As a community leader, Gama advocates for the integration of Palestinians into local communities. But what does integration mean? And who is to integrate with whom? AI defines integration as the process of combining or incorporating individuals or groups into a larger community. In this context, Gama proposes a permanent settlement of Palestinians in South Sudan. Is this feasible? Gama’s experience with the forced relocation of a community that integrated peacefully and accepted the host system, culture, and values might guide us. But which community is willing to integrate Palestinians into their system, culture, and values? Has Gama persuaded his community to support this challenging development?

3. Gama also compared South Sudanese in diaspora to the current situation, saying, “Those of you who have been refugees and got opportunities to resettle in Australia, America, Canada, etc., will agree with me.” Gama did not specify who took these refugees to their current locations, but implied that Palestinians should be equated with South Sudanese in Australia, Canada, etc. This is a faulty comparison. A person is considered a refugee only after leaving their country for safety. Palestinians are not refugees but internally displaced persons with the right to choose where to live. They are protected by their government, unlike in Israel, which forcibly expels them.

4. Gama warned opponents of his opinion against Islamophobia and called for humanity: “Our perceptions from the liberation struggle against the Arabs shouldn't cloud our hearts for humanity.” While it is true that South Sudanese fought against an Islamist regime, Gama should also understand the principles that define a refugee, an asylum seeker, and forced resettlement. There are already Muslim refugees in South Sudan, including Darfurian refugees. Why then should South Sudan deny Palestinians because of Islamism? South Sudanese by nature are number one in humanitarianism.

It is evident that while I respect Eng. Gama’s opinion, we must exercise caution with decisions that could impact us for generations. Biblically, Israel erred when God commanded them to destroy all Canaan inhabitants to prevent them from straying; failure to do so has led to the consequences they face today (as detailed in the Book of Judges). South Sudan is not ready to be part of these problems

As an intellectual, a government official, and a community leader, Gama is fully capable of advocating for this difficult judgement, since nothing is impossible in South Sudan. I kindly encourage my brother to reconsider his proposal, lest we remain too late, as the people of EES. We believe in your ability to achieve the unthinkable and the impossible, but this decision will be a betrayal of the people you serve.

While no one opposes saving refugee lives, I firmly oppose the forced resettlement of Palestinians in South Sudan by Israel, regardless of the terms. Let the UNHCR decide with the refugees where to settle them. The communities in South Sudan have enough problems to solve without adding more.

The Writer is a writer, critic, and teacher-pastor; defending the poor is my ambition. Psalm 82:2-4. 

Reach me through email. 👉👉👉 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MAGWI COUNTY UNDER CATTLE ATTACKS AGAIN.

    File Image July 11, 2025. To the Commissioner,  Magwi County Magwi County Maize Crops under Cattle Attack Again I am writing to inform you that Magwi County is once again facing an attack by cattle driven by the Dinka Balalo of Uganda. This is a direct result of an evacuation in response to the President's executive order aimed at stopping cattle-related conflicts in the Acholi region of Northern Uganda. As you may recall, the last conflict in Magwi County, which occurred in February, claimed lives and was not an isolated incident. Similar conflicts have recurred since 2014, when the Dinka Balalo from Bor forcefully entered Magwi County and the Equatoria region. Hon, you and the Magwi County community need to be aware of the potential resettlement of cattle in our lands. Our county's livelihood depends on its fertile soil, whereas the Dinka Balalo's survival relies on milk production. I urge you and your security team to remain vigilant and prevent any cattle ...
Post a Comment
Read more

IN HIS FOOTSTEPS: The Characters of A Leader's Heart

Meta AI "This is a faithful saying: If a man desires the position of a bishop, he desires a good work." 1 Timothy 3:1-7 Devotion 10. July 10, 2025 God's Design for Leadership   God alone is omniscient and sovereign. He designed leadership with specific character traits, appointing humanity to steward the world on His behalf. As we progress through Scripture, we observe God's design for leadership and the character traits required of each individual.   For example, He denied Saul leadership despite the pressure from the people. He chose David from among Jesse's children because David met His criteria, possessing the character and qualities worthy of leadership. In leadership, there are specific characteristics that leaders must embody to lead God's people. Paul listed these qualities in his letter to Timothy, emphasizing integrity, humility, and servanthood as essential for leading the church of God.   The Contrast Between God's Design and the Worl...
Post a Comment
Read more

ESTABLISH A SEPARATE AND INDEPENDENT DINKA KINGDOM WITHIN THEIR TERRITORIES.” Advocate Kenyi Advises President Kiir

Advocate & human rights lawyer Kenyi YA Kenyi said that Salva Kiir has long abandoned the national interest of South Sudan and instead chosen to pursue a narrow and divisive tribal agenda. From the time he was appointed deputy—based on tribal considerations—during the liberation struggle to all his subsequent roles within the regime, Kiir has consistently implemented policies that prioritize the interests of one ethnic group: the Jieng (Dinka), at the direct expense of the other 63 tribes of South Sudan.   Through his actions and appointments, he has systematically planted the seeds of division, ethnic discord, and mistrust among our people. Under his leadership, South Sudan—a sovereign nation built by the collective sacrifice of 64 tribes—has been reduced to what increasingly appears to be an absolute Jieng Kingdom, with Salva Kiir acting as its self-declared King.   If Kiir remains committed to advancing his tribal project, then we are left with no option but to gran...
Post a Comment
Read more